Hi Thomas,
Thanks for your comments about the Harry Potter - Heroes of Hogwarts Top Trumps.
We are sorry that you didn't enjoy playing them.
We appreciate your feedback and would like a chance to explain why some of the characters were scored as they were.
Firstly, an important point to note:
In this edition of Harry Potter Heroes of Hogwarts Top Trumps, (as with all Harry Potter Top Trumps), every statistic was approved by Warner Bros.
As the licensor, they had the final say as to what information, wording, statistics & character assets were used in each edition.
In order of your comments, please see the reason given:
1) Neville indeed displays courage on rare occasions, but generally, he is less courageous than others.
2) Why does Harry choose to challenge his headmaster for wisdom?
It may seem like a stretch, but I suppose it makes sense as Harry must come to terms with his own nature as a Horcrux and ultimately decide to sacrifice himself for the good of his friends and loved ones. He possesses the wisdom to make selfless decisions that no one else can.
An example of this is in the spiritual King’s Cross, Harry decides to return to Hogwarts and fight, instead of choosing the afterlife, which would have been a much easier path for him to take. Thus, he is both brave and wise.
3) Trelawney is a minor character, and Neville is relatively useless except for a few redeeming moments.
4) Hagrid had his wand snapped as punishment, so he is not a practicing wizard.
5) Fudge, on the other hand, is portrayed as inept, hence his name.
6) How did Fudge become Minister for Magic without possessing magic, cunning, courage, wisdom, or temperament?
That's precisely the question posed by the original story. Fudge is inept, paranoid, and ignorant, and his character exists to critique elected politicians. We maintain that his ratings are accurate, and they were approved by the licensor.
We hope that these reasons help explain things for you a little.
As we hate to think of our customers feeling disappointed with their item, we'd like to offer you a complimentary set of Top Trumps from our range at our official webshop:
https://toptrumps.com/collections/top-trumps
Please forward your UK address so I can send them to you.
Thank you.
Kind Regards
Rachel : )
